M.2 Investigating the Relationship between Image and Text in Illustrated Books, Part 2

Fri Nov 4 / 14:20 – 15:50 EDT
-voice_chat join

chair /

  • Larissa Vilhena, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland

The inherently interdisciplinary character of research into illustrated books, which comprises the fields of visual culture, literary criticism and illustration studies, permeates any attempt to study nineteenth-century illustrated editions of prose and verse. From the 1850s to the 1870s the Victorian ‘gift book’ proved extremely popular among the British middle-class readership. As a remarkable legacy of the Victorian era, the illustrated book influenced a wide range of artists, engravers and writers far beyond Britain and well into the twentieth century.

This session seeks to study the relationship between image and text in illustrated books. The main questions addressed are to what extent the visual is informed by the verbal and, conversely, how far the text is influenced by the image on the page. We welcome submissions from scholars at all stages of their careers to discuss illustrated volumes from any cultures from either the nineteenth or the twentieth century.

keywords: illustration, image, text, illustrated, book

M.2.1 A Dance Between Text and Image: The Pictorial Over the Textual in Walter Crane’s Fairy Tale Versions

  • Rachel Harris, Concordia University

The Victorian era was a time of state-sanctioned educational reforms, innovations in chromolithography, and alternative politics, where images made children's books increasingly prevalent. Contributing to these developments, artist Walter Crane (1845-1915) radicalized the colourful children's books and fairy stories that entered the book market. For his part, Crane was a committed socialist and a leading figure of the Arts and Crafts Movement who saw the educational potential of the arts to guide society towards a socialist future. Yet the text-to-image dynamic in Crane's toybooks tells but a part of the story for their reader-viewers readily assumed to be children alone. To better understand the pictorial power of Crane's full-page illustrated toybooks for children and adults alike, we must look at his politized oeuvre alongside nineteenth-century illustrated interpretations of well-known fairy stories such as Cinderella and Beauty and The Beast.

The visual impact of Victorian-era illustrated books comes to light through the range of pictorial interpretations of textual narratives alongside the cross-fertilization of images between genres. In the case of Crane, the inter-genre dynamic appears by cross-analyzing his illustrations for political magazines and children's books. In so doing, the allegorical figures of Capitalism, Socialism, Freedom, and Labour found in his overtly political illustrations become part of the artist's message that utopian socialism can make space for workers worldwide. Across Crane's toybooks—Cinderella (1873), Beauty and the Beast (1874), Little Red Riding Hood (1875), Sleeping Beauty (1876), Aladdin and the Wonderful Lamp (1876), and Jack and the Beanstalk (1895)—his political message travels between two types of publications, the political serial and children's books. Unlike other illustrated versions of these fairy tales, in Crane's, the subtly edited text concedes space to his full-page colour—amplifying the illustrator's socialist metanarrative in the dance between text and image. Ultimately Crane's toybooks offer an unexpected visual stream of nineteenth-century radicalism.

keywords: Illustrations, picturebooks, Victorian, Walter Crane, Socialism

Rachel Harris is a Scholarly Publishing Librarian at Concordia University, Montreal, Canada. Beyond working on open access publishing initiatives, including OER, she continues her research. Holding a doctorate in art history, her thesis work on the evolution of fairy tales within publishing history—from the 1690s to 1950s—led to her interpictorial approach of studying the meaning-making potential of the images, especially in terms of age, gender, race, and animality. Her research highlights the often-neglected visual power of the images that evolve with the continuities and constant changes that shape fairy tales. Harris' thesis, conference papers, courses taught, and writings contribute to the intersections between book history and art history.

M.2.2 From Art to Life: Faith Ringgold’s Flights of Imagination

  • Charles Reeve, OCAD University

“Write your own damn self,” the activist lawyer Florynce Kennedy retorted when Faith Ringgold lamented her sparse coverage—and write Ringgold did, from children’s books (starting with the acclaimed Tar Beach) to a critique of her daughter Michele Wallace’s Black Macho and the Myth of the Superwoman to the autobiography We Flew Over the Bridge. Yet these books neither initiate nor circumscribe Ringgold’s literary activity: before writing books, she augmented her art with text—tentatively (her “American People” series in the 1960s), then stridently (the “Feminist” series of the 1970s), then expansively (the “Women on the Bridge” series in the 1980s).

keywords: Faith Ringgold, children’s books, quilts, autobiography

An Associate Professor in the Faculty of Arts and Science and Faculty of Art at OCAD University, Charles Reeve has written on modern/contemporary art for many publications, including Art History, Biography, a/b, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Frieze, Parachute and the London Review of Books, and curated exhibitions featuring influential cultural producers like Jess Dobkin, Karim Rashid and Adel Abdessemed. He edited Inappropriate Bodies: art, design, and maternity (Demeter, 2019) with Rachel Epp Buller, with whom he now, in collaboration with Elena Marchevska, produces the Renewing the World podcast. His next book, Artists and their Autobiographies from Today to the Renaissance and Back, is out from Routledge this fall. Keenly interested in administration and governance, he is chair of Liberal Studies at OCAD as well as a past president of the OCAD Faculty Association, and a former president and former treasurer of L'Association d'art des universités du Canada/Universities Art Association of Canada.

M.2.3 Lines and Bodies: Perturbing the Relationship Between Image and Text

  • Rachel Anne Farquharson, OCAD University

The flatness of an image interferes with the perceived “truth of objects”—a continual attendant anxiety of the visual literary arts. A human’s perception of figurative flatness is all the more charged in relation to their own body—that is, one must grapple with the “metaphysics of human interiority”. In illustrated books, where first-order symbols such as drawings are contrasted with the abstract and somewhat detached second-order symbols of text, readers are awakened to a powerful and bewildering dissonance: the anxiety of the flat. Here, the depth of dimension evoked by prose releases the visual from the responsibility of the ‘real’, precipitating confusion in the body’s sensory cognition.

John Tenniel’s illustrations for Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland [1865] prove instrumental in revealing alienating visual devices accompanying imaginative stories and illuminate the dynamic between author and artist in a manuscript’s completion. Drawing closer to the present, the idiom in which artist/writers like Max Ernst, Kara Walker, Henry Darger, and Edward Gorey create their work owes its superstructure to the paradox between the truth of being and the false promises of images when informed by the verbal. An oversight of scholarship—which will be the focus of my talk—is the way in which the paradox between text and image can provoke the body. The nappy hair, scrawny limbs, and voided black body of Walker’s Negress mistress exhume uncomfortable racist imagery from African American folktales popular during the 19th century. Darger’s The Story of the Vivian Girls, in What Is Known as the Realms of the Unreal [1940-60] ignites the intellectual riddle of narratives turned both familiar and fear-provoking by accompanying imagery. The consequential mixture of attraction and anxiety is a bodily reaction that arrives unconsciously through a progressive journey between the spaces of visual culture, prose, and two-dimensional illustration.

keywords: flatness, phenomenology, self-reflexivity, text, illustration

Rachel Anne Farquharson is a BIPOC art historian, curator, and former professional ballerina. Her research pursues the phenomenological effects of two-dimensional, often paper-based, art and its psychological architecture. With a penchant for the relationship between image and text, her publications and curatorial practice have explored historical and contemporary illustration, paper ephemera, and the sensorial space of children’s picture books. Farquharson has lectured at the China Academy of Arts, Concordia University, Ryerson University, the University of British Columbia, and MOCA, Toronto, as well as taken part in panel discussions at OCAD U. Her critical essays have been featured in 3x3 Magazine of Contemporary Illustration and C magazine; The Tate Britain has published her analytical writings on the Gallery’s collection and new acquisitions. She holds a Masters of Modern and Contemporary Art from Christie’s Education in London, U.K. and an Honours B.A. and B.Sc. from the University of Toronto.

arrow_upward arrow_forward